Can I Stop Yet?
If Josh gets into an ace university, it's only because A Short History of Tractors in Ukrainian didn't catch my interest. I'd avoided reading a friend's borrowed Admission Matters for two months, passing over the intimating tome for novels, memoirs and the occasional People magazine. It sat on my coffee table week after week, brushed aside by not only me but also my upper education-bound son and his impressively educated father. Me? Why should I read it? I did my job as a parent, I reasoned. I'm done. Josh is a good kid with a good future. If he wants to get into the Ivy League, let him figure out the finer details.
Oh, the nasty looks I've gotten for saying that! Oh, the curt little lectures I've heard! "You've got to read the books!" parents of former teens admonished. "Take him on the road! Force him to see the campuses!" And, unspoken, "Gather the paperwork! Fill it out! Run it by an expert! Buy the recruiters diamonds! Sleep with them if you have to!"
Apparently getting into college is no longer just the high school senior's job. Now the effort is a family affair.
Granted, the whole process is tougher than it was when we were kids. Competition is stiffer for the best schools, and seemingly every other A student in America has been privately tutored since two years before they took the PSAT and now have new tutors to see them through the application process. Josh has earned his way up the academic ladder on his own -- by studying -- and I'll support him in any way he wants. But only the obvious stuff. Want me to drive you to community college so you have a solid shot at valedictorian? Want me to pay for an online SAT course? Heck, I'll even cook you a nice breakfast the morning of the exam and I'll sharpen your pencils. But until my stack of to-reads ran short, I refused to do more.
Here's how I see it: I put in the efforts up front. I refrained from drinking while I pregnant. Wine and coffee -- both taboo. I breast fed for 10 months even though I suffered excruciating pain for more weeks than I care to recall. I stocked the house with kiddie books and read them all he wanted -- and he sometimes wanted 40 in one sitting. "You can watch TV the rest of your life," I reasoned. "Be there for him now."Jigsaw puzzles, Candy Land, Trouble ... I may have taught him games too well, because I can't even once keep up in Scrabble Scoring Anagrams. I sat through years of school meetings and basketball games. We baked and we swam and we talked.
And then he was gone, pretty much. Josh is responsible, he gets good grades, he volunteers, he holds a job. I'm done, right? Now it's time to enjoy each other's company, occasionally wrestle over the remote control, and hope for happy Sunday dinners when he can pull himself away from his friends.
So why does everyone think I'm the one who has to get this kid into college? If he can pull off grades better than I ever had in classes harder than any I ever took, shouldn't he be reading Admission Matters? Apparently even the authors don't think so. While they pretend to write for kids, they frequently address parents directly, such as when they suggest that we old-timers leave certain documents out where our teens might happen to come across them.
I succumbed out of boredom and now find myself intrigued. The book has excellent insider tips. I'm making mental notes of what to tell Josh and plotting when to ante up the information so he'll be most likely to absorb it. I even Xeroxed three pages last night -- twice, one set for him, another for his best friend.
I guess I'm not done after all. If you catch me ordering his textbooks in Fall 2011, hurl the "helicopter" word at me and admonish me to spend all my excess parenting energy on my other son. I still have an excuse -- and the desire -- to run his life! Although I am so very tired.
www.RonaGindin.com

Can't wait to read your blog after you fill out Josh's FAFSA next January!!!
Reply to this
What's a FAFSA? (Tell Josh, not me!)
Reply to this
that's the application for financial aid. It's about as complicated as figuring out how to solve the national debt, blind-folded, upside down, horse-back riding. But no problem. Loved your post, Rona. Caroline has made college a simple task. She wants to go to one school, that is next to impossible to get into, is incredibly small. and she refuses to write the application or essays. Fun is. However, you know the Koppelman Confidence. By the way, the school costs, $52K a year. And who is going to pay for that ? OH MY! Some how, it was easier when they were babies, wasn't it ?
Reply to this
The first time I heard helicopter parent I was so offended...
We do everything to raise our kids and help them to make wonderful choices...but in the end "the system" doesn't really let them be independent.
I don't remember my parents going t...o college orientation with me. When I took my daughter there was a separate whole program for parents and then they have the nerve to say..."how many of you have texted or relieved a text from your child?" 90% raised their hands and then they told us to cut the cord. Why are we there with them at orientation? Should we turn back the technology clock and go backwards? Should we not have input into the classes they are taking or professions they are exploring?
If being a helicopter parent means we have stronger ties and relations with our kids so be it...but I agree with you. I am not filling out the dam paperwork for them! They can lead me to the water and I will drink beside them once there.
Reply to this
It's a tough world out there. So? It's always been a tough world given the resources available at the time. Helicopter parents can cripple young men. It seems to me that the main goal of parenting is to teach and encourage your children to be self-reliant. That means doing hard things, difficult things--like standing by and watching your kids struggle and fail and letting them pick up their own pieces. But, that is how young people figure out life. If you do it for them, you rob them of the very experiences that help them grow. "Standing by" is real love. The love that leads to hovering is selfish and focuses on assuaging YOUR feelings of anxiety.
Not hovering is hard--the correct behavior IS often hard. You probably learned that because someone let you make your own mistakes.
Reply to this
Let Michael read the book. If you feel you need to be involved you will be. You've always done what is best for your kids. You are a great mother!!!!!!
Reply to this
have you read claudia dreifus' book on higher education -- check her out -- she's a writer too.. and a friend of mine -- for all of my life.. she writes for the NY Times..and writes on why college is a big rip off... my step brother wrote the same kind of book -- the big college rip off.. how kids are stuck paying these college loans -- for private schools --- and the ROI is just not worth it. especially when you add in law school -- and all that crap.. my kid wants to go to a school that cost s 52K that's 200K before graduate school -- what does she need to earn before she gets an ROI, for that?? really.. Claudia has some really good points.. and so does Marc in his book.. Of course, I kid him -- considering he went to Emory and my dad sported him for his Masters and of course his PhD. Of course, i never got my PhD. I worked like a slave. LOL.. xoxoxo N
Reply to this